Image Map

Sunday, March 11, 2012

Chocolate Salted Caramel Pie (ie.Best Pie EVER!)

(Note : This photo is the dulche de leche version)

After I made the original version of this pie the first time I was always looking for another reason to make it again.   I was also thinking I need to change it.   The crust on this pie is so easy and I love that it is gluten free.  So over the last year the one thought that would never leave my head was adding a caramel layer to the pie.  However, over the year I got side tracked with other recipes.

One fine day a week ago...there was a reason.  Yippee!  It was the birthday of my good friend Katie who I work with and I wanted to bake her a birthday treat.   I had to do a little re-con and ask her husband secretly through facebook what she loves for dessert.   His response was anything coconut, red velvet, lemon and salted caramel.   Ding Ding Ding! We have a winner, I can make the pie.  I was so excited I could barely keep it a secret from her.

The original version of this pie (sans caramel) is the most viewed item on my blog.   Trust me when I say this,  this version is SOOOOOOO much better.     I also actually made two versions of this pie one with salted caramel and one with salted dulche de leche.   I wanted to see what version might be better, there is a clear winner.
coconut, salted caramel, chocolate, pie, bestpie

I made some changes to the crust from the previous version aswell, the original had way to much coconut.

Chocolate Salted Caramel Pie

(Loosely adapted from Martha Stewart)
Makes one 9-inch pie.


  • 1/4 cup + 1 tbsp unsalted butter, softened
  • 3 cups unsweetened shredded coconut
  • 1 cup sweetened shredded coconut
  • 2 tbsp xylitol or granulated sugar

  • 2/3 cup heavy cream
  • 6 ounces bittersweet chocolate, finely chopped (72% cacao)
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 1/3 cup water
  • 1/3 cup heavy cream
  • 2 tsp sea salt
or exclude all of the caramel ingredients and use homemade dulce de leche --> Recipe

1 Make the crust: Preheat the oven to 350°F. In a food processor, process butter and 2 cups of unsweetened coconut and xylitol until mixture starts to stick together, 1 to 2 minutes. Transfer to a medium bowl. Combine this mixture with all the remaining coconut,  using your hands to bring together

2 Press coconut mixture into bottom and up sides of pie pan to form crust, leaving top edges loose and fluffy. Cover the crust lightly with tin foil over the edges, and cut a hole in the center.  Keeping the edges covered to prevent burning. Bake until center begins to brown, 10 to 15 minutes; remove foil and bake until edges are browned, 4 to 5 minutes more. Transfer crust to a wire rack to cool completely.

3) Make the caramel sauce.   Place sugar and water in a sauce pan or small dutch oven over medium-high heat.  Allow the mixture to boil until mixture begins to darken, watching carefully so the mixture doesn't burn.
I always keep a pastry brush and small cup of water close by, and occasionally brush the sides of the pan to prevent crystallization.  If you noticed uneven browning, you may have to give the pan a light swirl.

4) When the mixture has turned to a medium amber add the heavy cream, whisking constantly.   The mixture will expand and bubble from the steam.   Add sea salt and stir to combine.

5) Allow the caramel to cool for approx 15 minutes before pouring into the cooled coconut crust.

6)) Make the chocolate filling:  In a small sauce pan bring cream just to a boil.  While cream is heating up, place chopped chocolate into a medium heatproof bowl.  Pour the cream over the chocolate and let sit for 10 minutes to allow chocolate to melt.  Stir to combine and melt remaining chocolate.  The mixture should be smooth and completely melted. Pour onto the caramel layer, smooth out if needed.  Refrigerate until filling is set, 1 hour or up to 1 day. 

If you are using the dulche de leche, omit the caramel steps and pour half can of dulche de lech over the coconut crust and top that with the chocolate.

I think this may be my favorite pie of all time. The people at work were two thumbs to both versions.  I even got a note left on my desk with the statement "AMAZING PIE".    If you have to choose between the salted caramel and the dulche de leche I would choose the salted caramel version.  It is less creamy but salted caramel just has that extra UMPH vs. dulche de leche.

Make this for your Easter dinner, your family won't be disappointed!!

MEG's RATING: D-EEEEEE-LICIOUS.   (That is one E above the limit!)

Pi Day Pie Party


  1. I love the caramel layer oozing out, and I don't think I've ever seen or heard of a coconut crust before, looks amazing!

  2. Wow Meg! This looks amazing! I may be drooling on my keyboard over here.

  3. Oooooooo!!!!! This looks incredible! I adore coconut. A whole crust made of coconut would be heaven. Love the layer of chocolate ganache too. Mmmm! Definitely have to make this.

    Hope you had a great weekend! :)

  4. wow, this really looks and sounds incredibly good! definitely have to make it!

  5. Can you provide the link to the original Martha Stewart recipe?

  6. Whoa, this looks amazing!! Definitely need to give it a try, wow! :)

  7. What a 'yummylicious' dessert!

    Chef Al dente On going event: Gimme GREEN!

  8. Wow! This looks amazing, I never would have thought of using coconut with salted caramel but now I really want to try it! x

  9. Mmmm coconut, salted caramel, and dark chocolate. This looks oddly intriguing and delightful at the same time! One question - What step is the salt added for the caramel?

  10. The sea salt is added to the caramel after the cream.

  11. coconut crust, great idea! looks delish!

  12. I die. I make first. Then I die. From happy.

  13. Love all your comments. Thanks all. You will love this pie.

  14. Do you think it would be ok to substitute light cream for the heavy cream?

  15. You could try the substitution for the caramel sauce. But I don't think the chocolate ganache would set the same way with a light cream.

  16. Great recipe - have made it a few times, making adjustments and finding the correct Australian conversions along the way. I even made a vegan version which was a big hit!

    FYI for any Australian cooks, I found it worked best not to convert US cups to AU cups, but just to use with AU cup measures - worked fine, as the ratios remained the same. The best crust recipe adaptation I found was using 5 cups unsweetened shredded coconut, 1/4 cup + 1tbsp coconut butter, and 1/4 cup icing sugar (not mixture) - the coconut butter helps set the crust better than dairy butter, and tastes great. The icing sugar instead of granulated sugar and using only 5 cups coconut helps to set the crust better too.

    For AU users, I found the best ganache recipe was to use X ml of double cream to X grams of dark chocolate - so for 300g chocolate using 300mL cream. I made some of the tarts with way more ganache - I think using 300g chocolate is a good amount.

    VEGAN: making the crust with coconut butter, and the ganache with coconut milk - use slightly lower ratio, ie 250mL coconut milk to 300g chocolate. Worked REALLY well, coconut flavour not overpowering as you might expect, no one eating it could tell it was made with coconut milk.

    Lastly, love the salted caramel addition, but I would double the amount next time, as this recipe only made a thin layer and it's so yummy, I want more of it! Haven't attempted vegan salted caramel yet, very curious to see if it would work using coconut cream though, will have to try this soon.

    Thanks for a great recipe and the gorgeous pictures that inspired me to make this in the first place!


  17. This sounds amazing! I am going to make it for my mom for Mother's Day. Quick question--How would you store it? In the fridge or just covered on the countertop? Thanks for the recipe! Can't wait to try it:)

  18. Store it in the fridge or some place cool.

  19. Sorry, but I can't stop looking at these pictures! I have never seen such a beautiful cake before. The coconut crust is a sensation!

  20. Thanks Felia, it is one of my favorite recipes.

  21. What size is your pie pan? (looking closely it looks like a disposable foil "plate" which in Brazil is very used to take food away from restaurants...)

  22. I am seriously drooling over here...this is absolutely amazing looking!!! Love that coconut crust!!!

  23. Oh MY GOODNESS!!! I need this in my life NOW! That crust is calling my name and I love salted caramel. WOW!

  24. This doesn't look too appetizing to me, but my husband would love it!

  25. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  26. It looks so good !
    Congratulations !
    Fernanda from "Cooking for Real".

  27. This pie looks spectacular! All that slated caramel oozing out!! Delicious :)

  28. Holy bejesus, I didn't know you could fall in love with a potential recipe but I just did. Chocolate? Caramel? In a PIE? Wow. Wow. That's all I can say. I LOVE IT!

    1. You will love it. It is seriously my all time favorite pie.


LOVE your comments! Please let me know you stopped by. I always try to reply to the comment via e-mail, but I can only do that if you are not a "NO REPLY" commenter on Google. Check your Settings or reply via a different account.

Sorry I had to add on the word verification, spammers are out of control!


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...